When facing criminal charges in Ohio, the stakes are high, and every move counts. Pretrial motions and other defense strategies can be decisive factors in your case, allowing you to challenge the evidence and set the stage for your benefit.

While you’ve probably heard of court motions before, these aren’t just legal formalities. Effective pretrial motions can be the difference between conviction, drastic charge or penalty reductions, and your freedom.

Explore pretrial motions and how they can change Ohio criminal cases.

What Are Pretrial Motions in Ohio?

Pretrial motions are formal requests made to the court before a formal trial begins. They aim to set the boundaries for the trial, challenge the prosecution’s evidence, and clarify specific legal issues.

These motions can significantly influence the outcome of Ohio criminal cases, potentially leading to reduced charges, dismissal, or favorable plea agreements.

1. Motion to Dismiss

This motion argues that the charges should be dropped entirely. Grounds for dismissal can include lack of evidence, violations of your constitutional rights, or procedural errors.

Imagine facing theft charges for an offense you didn’t commit, and there’s clear evidence proving your innocence. A Motion to Dismiss can argue that the charges should be dropped entirely due to lack of evidence or procedural errors. This motion can save you from the stress and expense of a trial.

2. Motion to Suppress Evidence

A motion to suppress evidence seeks to prevent unlawful evidence from being used in court. For example, if evidence were obtained unlawfully—such as through an illegal search and seizure—this motion would try to prevent it from being used.

Successfully suppressing key evidence can weaken the prosecution’s case and could lead to charges being reduced or dismissed.

3. Motion for Change of Venue

Change of Venue Motions requests that the trial be moved to a different location. This is often necessary when pretrial publicity or local biases prevent a fair trial.

Suppose you’re facing serious charges in a small Ohio town like Ravenna, where the case has received extensive media coverage. A Motion for Change of Venue can suggest moving the trial to a different area to ensure you have an impartial jury. Such motions can help secure a fair trial by avoiding potential local prejudices.

 4. Motion for Discovery

A Motion for Discovery compels the prosecution to provide all the evidence they plan to use at trial. This ensures that your defense team can access all relevant information, allowing for thorough preparation.

If you’re charged with a DUI or drug offense, there may be test results and other evidence that you won’t have immediate access to or sometimes are unaware of its existence. A Motion for Discovery forces the prosecution to reveal their evidence, helping your defense attorney prepare a robust strategy and potentially identify weaknesses.

5. Motion in Limine

A Motion in Limine prevents certain evidence from being introduced at trial. It’s often used to keep prejudicial, irrelevant, or inadmissible evidence from influencing the jury.

Suppose there’s a piece of evidence that, while not directly related to your case, could unfairly prejudice the jury against you. A Motion in Limine can be filed to prevent this evidence from being presented, ensuring the focus remains on the facts.

6. Motion to Sever

A Motion to Sever requests that the charges or defendants allegedly involved in a criminal case be tried separately. This is often necessary when being tried alongside co-defendants whose actions might unfairly impact the jury’s perception of you.

For instance, if you’re charged with a minor role in a bank robbery, but your co-defendant is accused of violent crimes during the robbery, their more severe actions could bias the jury against you. A Motion to Sever can separate your trial from theirs, ensuring your case is considered independently, reducing the risk of being unfairly judged based on their actions.

7. Motion for a Speedy Trial

A Motion for a Speedy Trial requests that the trial be expedited to avoid unnecessary delays, ensuring your case is heard promptly.

If your trial keeps getting delayed, it can be incredibly stressful and disruptive to your life. A Motion for a Speedy Trial can push your case to be heard sooner rather than later, helping to bring a quicker resolution and reducing the anxiety and uncertainty you might be facing.

Other Ohio Pretrial Motions

Pretrial motions in Ohio are not limited to those listed. Based on your unique situation, charges, and case particulars, your defense attorney may suggest others to help support your case. Here are some other pretrial motions that can impact a criminal case:

Motion for Continuance

A Motion for Continuance requests to postpone a court proceeding or trial to a later date. This motion is typically filed to provide additional time for the defense to prepare, gather evidence, or accommodate scheduling conflicts.

Motion for Bail Reduction

A Motion for Bail Reduction seeks to lower the amount of bail the court sets. This motion argues that the current bail amount is excessive and that a reduced amount would still ensure the defendant’s appearance at future court dates.

Motion for a Bill of Particulars

A Motion for a Bill of Particulars requests the prosecution to provide detailed information about the charges against the defendant. This motion helps the defense understand the specific allegations and prepare an effective defense.

Motion to Quash

A Motion to Quash challenges the validity of a subpoena, warrant, or other legal process. This motion argues that the legal process is defective or was improperly issued and should be nullified.

Motion for Habeas Corpus

A Motion for Habeas Corpus challenges the legality of the defendant’s detention or imprisonment. This motion asserts that the defendant is being held without sufficient cause and requests immediate release.

Motion to Compel

A Motion to Compel requests the court to order the opposing party to comply with a discovery request. This motion is often used to obtain evidence or information that the prosecution has withheld.

Motion for Mental Health Evaluation

A Motion for Mental Health Evaluation requests that the defendant undergo a psychiatric or psychological assessment. This motion is typically filed when there are concerns about the defendant’s mental competency to stand trial or criminal responsibility.

When Are Pretrial Motions Appropriate?

Pretrial motions are critical to the Ohio criminal court process and can be appropriate at various stages. Typically, motions are filed after the arraignment, where you formally hear the charges against you and enter a plea before the trial begins. This period is crucial for your defense team to gather evidence, identify weaknesses, and determine the best strategies.

Filing pretrial motions involves thorough preparation by your attorney, who gathers evidence and legal precedents to support the arguments. Once the motion is prepared, it is filed with the court, detailing the legal basis and the specific relief sought. The court then schedules a hearing where the defense and prosecution present their arguments. After considering both sides, the judge will rule on the motion immediately or after further review.

Regardless of the specific motion or case details, you should discuss all your options and avenues, including what legal motions are viable, with an experienced criminal defense attorney who can determine the best strategy.

How Pretrial Motions Benefit Criminal Cases

  • Dismissal or Reduction of Charges: Successfully arguing a motion to dismiss or suppress evidence can lead to a reduction or complete dismissal of charges, often the best possible outcome.
  • Exclude Damaging Evidence: A motion to suppress can prevent prejudicial or unlawfully obtained evidence from being used against you, weakening the prosecution’s case.
  • Strategic Advantages: Pretrial motions can force the prosecution to reveal their strategy and evidence early, allowing your defense team to prepare counterarguments and build a stronger defense.
  • Negotiation Leverage: Winning key pretrial motions can significantly leverage plea negotiations, leading to more favorable terms or lesser charges.

Charged in Ohio? Discuss Pretrial Motions with Erb Legal

Pretrial motions are among your most powerful defense tools if you’re accused of a crime. They are not just procedural steps. Instead, they are what lets defendants challenge evidence, clarify legal issues, and protect their rights, often leading to reduced charges or case dismissal. At Erb Legal, our experience and successful record handling pretrial motions have consistently resulted in favorable outcomes throughout Ohio.

Don’t leave your fate to chance. Contact Erb Legal today to discuss how pretrial motions can help your case. Call (330) 869-9007 or contact us for a consultation.

legal Blog

featured blog post image

May 31, 2024

7 Ohio Pretrial Motions That Can Help Your Criminal Case

Category: Criminal Defense

Read Blog
featured blog post image

April 24, 2024

What to Know for Your First Ohio Criminal Court Appearance

Category: Criminal Defense

Read Blog
featured blog post image

February 16, 2024

Ohio Criminal Defense Explained: What is the Burden of Proof?

Category: Criminal Defense

Read Blog
featured blog post image

November 08, 2023

Ohio Issue 2 & Navigating Recreational Marijuana Laws in Ravenna

Category: Child Custody

Read Blog
View All Blogs