When you are charged with a crime, you are innocent until proven guilty. The prosecution (which represents the state of Ohio in criminal matters) must prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. It’s important to understand what this means so you know what you’re up against.

Ohio’s legal system involves multiple courts and types of cases, from civil to criminal. Each of these types of cases has a different burden of proof that must be met for the parties to win a case. By understanding the criminal burden of proof in Ohio, you can build the strongest defense possible and, in some cases, proactively help your case.

What Is a Presumption of Innocence?

In Ohio, and throughout the United States, there is a presumption of innocence when you are charged with a crime. That means that you are considered innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The burden lies with the prosecution to convincingly prove that you committed a crime.

You do not have to prove your innocence. You have a right to remain silent and have a fair trial without having to actively demonstrate your innocence.

Imagine you are accused of stealing a car. In court, you’re not required to prove that you did not steal the car. Instead, the prosecutor must provide clear evidence that you committed the crime. This could involve presenting video surveillance, fingerprints, witness testimony, or any other evidence that points to your guilt. You have the right to remain silent, and you don’t need to present any evidence or testimony to show your innocence. If the prosecution can’t prove your guilt convincingly, you are entitled to an acquittal.

This presumption ensures that no one is punished without sufficient evidence of their guilt and protects individuals from the power of the state.

Types of Burdens of Proof in Ohio

“Beyond a reasonable doubt” is a high standard. It means that if there is any reasonable explanation for the actions of the accused other than guilt, then they must be acquitted (found not guilty). The reasonable doubt standard is one of the most difficult to achieve in the legal world.

It is worth noting that in civil cases, the burden of proof is “by a preponderance of the evidence” in Ohio and throughout the United States. That means that the defendant more likely than not took the actions of which they are being accused.

Burden of Production

The burden of production is closely related to the burden of proof. It defines the burden of going forward in a criminal case for the prosecution (the government). It is the minimum amount of evidence the prosecution needs to get to the starting line before presenting their full case.

In a criminal case, the prosecution must meet a lower burden of production to get a hearing. If they fail to meet the burden of production, then the case may be dismissed.

If, however, you present an affirmative defense in Ohio, you have the burden of production to show that your actions are justified by that defense. For example, if you claim that you lacked the mental capacity to commit murder, then you have the burden of production to show that you couldn’t understand the nature of your actions to form criminal intent.

Burden of Persuasion

The burden of persuasion refers to the party that is responsible for convincing the judge or jury of their claim to the required standard of proof. There is a higher bar of convincing the court than there is with a burden of production.

The burden of persuasion in a criminal case indicates that the prosecution must meet the standard of proof (beyond a reasonable doubt), which means there can be no significant doubt remaining.

If the prosecution fails to meet the burden of persuasion, the case may be dismissed against you.

The Standard for Proving Guilt

Different legal standards have varying requirements for proving guilt. Some common legal standards used for proving guilt in Ohio include, but are not limited to:

Clear and convincing evidence – This is a higher standard of proof used in certain legal and non-legal contexts to demonstrate the truth of a claim. It falls somewhere between the preponderance of the evidence standard (more likely than not) used in most civil cases and the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard required in criminal cases.
Clear probability – Although this term isn’t a standard of proof recognized in most legal systems, it may be understood as conveying strong support for a claim. However, it lacks the legal weight associated with terms like “clear and convincing evidence.”
Probable cause – This refers to specific facts known to an official (usually a police officer) that would lead a reasonable person to believe a crime has been committed (in the context of arrest) or evidence of a crime will be found (in the context of a search warrant).
Reasonable suspicion – This refers to specific facts known to an official (usually a police officer) that would lead a reasonable person to suspect criminal activity may occur, but not necessarily that it has been committed.

How The Burden of Proof Impacts Your Case

Burdens of proof impact case outcomes because if they are not met by the police officer, investigator, prosecutor, or other official, then the government may lose its case, and charges will be dismissed against the defendant in a criminal case.

For example, if a police officer does not have enough facts to satisfy the required burden of proof to meet reasonable suspicion, then they cannot obtain a search warrant. If they do conduct a search without appropriate reasonable suspicion, then any evidence obtained may be thrown out or suppressed. This can lead to a win for the defendant, and the case may be dismissed.

The Importance of Legal Representation

It’s essential to have an experienced Ohio criminal lawyer who understands how to develop defenses in Ohio criminal cases. Your legal representation can help you effectively fight criminal charges in Ohio.

A criminal defense attorney who is familiar with the Ohio criminal justice system can effectively challenge the prosecution’s evidence and protect your rights. Your attorney needs to know how to use burdens of proof against the prosecution to get key evidence suppressed and your case dismissed. Targeting burdens of proof and evidence in Ohio courts is also an excellent way to force the prosecution to negotiate with you when seeking reduced charges.

A skilled attorney can help you challenge the prosecution’s case in Ohio, navigate the burdens of proof, and achieve favorable outcomes in your case.

Can I Win My Case with an Affirmative Defense?

In criminal cases, an affirmative defense is a legal strategy where you admit to committing the act but argue that justifying or excusing circumstances make you not legally culpable. It is possible to win with this strategy, but it is a difficult path to take.

If you want to use an affirmative defense in Ohio, you will be transferring the burden of proof away from the prosecution and onto you. You are not required to prove your innocence. However, if you choose to present an affirmative defense, then you effectively must prove that you are innocent. This is much more difficult than just letting the prosecution do all the work and meet their burden of proof.

The Lawyers at Erb Legal Can Help

Criminal cases require the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you committed a crime. You do not have to prove your innocence. However, it can be tempting to explain things. You should avoid shifting the burden to yourself. Instead, let your Ohio criminal lawyer handle the legal issues and protect your rights by using burdens of proof to create an effective trial and defense strategy.

Erb Legal has a team of Ohio criminal defense lawyers ready to fight for you. In Portage, Medina, or Summit County, Ohio, call Erb Legal at (330) 869-9007 or request a consultation.

legal Blog